This is a photograph that is not destined to become famous. That’s Kevin Prendergast with Jesse Niinimaki, Kevin Lowe and Lorne Davis.
The Oilers have just drafted the Finn, the Habs have left the stage with Chris Higgins and a couple of picks later Los Angeles will take Denis Grebeshkov. Jarret Stoll is wondering if he’ll go on day one.
Such is the nature of the draft.
I followed drafts as a kid. I remember the 1971 draft and I anticipated the 1973 Amateur Draft. If my own son looked forward to something like a hockey league’s annual draft there’s a chance I’d slide him into a room with an “expert” in the field of social interaction but there you go I’ve confessed it.
Anyway, back then you waited for the Hockey News (I do recall a newspaper article detailing Denis Potvin as the top overall pick and that Atlanta had drafted Tom Lysiak from Medicine Hat) and they gave you the background (one of the things that all this information robs one of is waiting for something you really want. The July issue of the Hockey News was such a thing) on the draft and the trades.
The one thing I remember most about that draft was that Bob Gainey’s scoring numbers were awful for a forward. He had 22 goals in 52 games in the OHA and the guy drafted before him (Blaine Stoughton) had 58 goals in 66 games in the WHL. There was a reference to his checking ability but you’ve got to be a helluva checker to go 8th overall when you can’t pot 30 in junior at age 19. In any era.
One thing I’ve always looked for is a way to measure draft performance by team. That’s a little different than measuring it by league (I think we can all agree scouts do a damn good job in grabbing most of the top talent each season by selection 100) and it requires some “handicapping” for where a team is selecting each player.
I’ve toyed with this for decades (which really speaks volumes about how I spend my time) and “games played” has always been the line in the sand that works best because all positions are represented. Goalies get punished the most by this measure but we can make allowances for it just by being aware of it and make it close enough for jazz.
If we attempted to “tax” the high picks and let the selections after #100 remain “tax free” could we come up with a way to measure individual draft performances. What would it look like? Would it make sense?
Let’s try doing one right now. Let’s say that for a specific draft year we’ll “tax” thusly:
- Top 10 picks: 60 games per season after age 20
- Picks 11-25: 40 games per season after age 20
- Picks 26-50: 30 games per season after age 20
- Picks 51-100: 20 games per season after age 20
- Picks 100+ Tax free
Since we have no idea what it will look like, let’s roll with it and come back to the tax system later (I find that funny in a Brian Mulroney kind go way). I’m going to use the 2001 Entry Draft since Kevin Prendergast is going to be the subject of this blog over the next while and let’s do the entire Canadian division.
2001 Edmonton Oilers Draft (+80)
- 13th Ales Hemsky (GP: 322-160tax= +162)
- 43rd Doug Lynch (GP: 2-120tax= -118)
- 52nd Eddie Caron (GP: 0-80tax= -80)
- 84th Kenny Smith (GP: 0-80tax= -80)
- 133rd Jussi Markkanen (GP: +128 no tax)
- 154th Jake Brenk (GP: 0 no tax)
- 185th Mikael Svensk (GP: 0 no tax)
- 215th Dan Baum (GP: 0 no tax)
- 248th Kari Haakana (GP: +13 no tax)
- 272nd Ales Pisa (GP: +53 no tax)
- 278th Shay Stephenson (GP: +2 no tax)
Does that look fair? We penalize them for the 3 picks in the top 100 that didn’t work out but they should be, right? Prendergast himself is always talking about not making mistakes in the top 100 and so it had a major impact. Hemsky’s emergence at 19 and Markkanen being a useful player made up for it plus a little bit. If I were going to change the system at all it might be to make the penalty for that 84th pick less severe but let’s keep it for now.
2001 Calgary Flames Draft (-16)
- 14th Chuck Kobasew (GP: 272-160tax= +112)
- 41st Andrei Taratukhin (GP: 0-120tax= -120)
- 56th Andrei Medvedev (GP: 0-80tax= -80)
- 108th Tomi Maki (GP: +1 no tax)
- 124th Igor Shastin (GP 0 no tax)
- 145th Jim Hakewill (GP 0 no tax)
- 164th Yuri Trubachev (GP 0 no tax)
- 207th Garett Bembridge (GP 0 no tax)
- 220th David Moss (GP +71 no tax)
- 233rd Joe Campbell (GP 0 no tax)
- 251st Ville Hamalainen (GP 0 no tax)
Looks right to me. Like Edmonton, Calgary gets rewarded for getting a player who covered the bet in the first round and then paid heavily for the misses later in the top 100. A questions that we can think about here are “does this system penalize the players 26-100 too heavily since their chances of being anything aren’t statistically great?”
2001 Vancouver Canucks Draft (+172)
- 16th RJ Umberger (GP: 203-160tax= +43)
- 66th Fedor Fedorov (GP: 18-80= -62)
- 114th Evgeny Gladskikh (GP 0 no tax)
- 151st Kevin Bieksa (GP 132 no tax)
- 212th Jason King (GP 59 no tax)
- 245th Konstantin Mikhailov (GP 0 no tax)
Nice draft by the Canucks, they got a nice first round pick and then a very useful player in the no tax zone. Plus Jason King who has played in the NHL about as much as Marc Pouliot.
2001 Ottawa Senators Draft (+621)
- 2nd Jason Spezza (GP: 293-240tax= +53)
- 23rd Tim Gleason (GP: 237-160tax= +77)
- 81st Neil Komadoski (GP: 0-80tax= -80)
- 99th Ray Emery (GP: 123-80tax= +43)
- 127th Christoph Schubert (GP 189 no tax)
- 162nd Stefan Schuauer (GP 0 no tax)
- 193rd Brooks Laich (GP 204 no tax)
- 218th Jan Platil (GP 0 no tax)
- 223rd Brandon Bochenski (GP 113 no tax)
- 235th Neil Petruic (GP 0 no tax)
- 256th Gregg Johnson (GP 0 no tax)
- 286th Toni Dahlman (GP 22 no tax)
That was a nice draft. Spezza points out an interesting problem for this. If we were going to do this over a long period (say 25 years) would it be a good idea to end the tax at some point? Say after 10 years? I don’t know, just thinking out loud.
2001 Montreal Canadiens Draft (+5)
- 7th Mike Komisarek (GP: 272-240tax= +32)
- 25th Alexander Perezhogin (GP: 125-160tax= -35)
- 37th Duncan Milroy (GP: 5-120tax= -115)
- 71st Tomas Plekanec (GP 202-80tax= +122)
- 109th Martti Jarventie (GP 1 no tax)
- 171st Eric Himelfarb (GP 0 no tax)
- 203rd Andrew Archer (GP 0 no tax)
- 266th Viktor Ujcik (GP 0 no tax)
A draft that is better than it looks currently. Habs got 3 nice players in the top 100 who will more than cover their bet and Milroy should play some eventually.
2001 Toronto Maple Leafs Draft (-69)
- 17th Carlo Colaiacovo (GP: 81-160tax= -79)
- 39th Karl Pilar (GP: 90-120tax= -30)
- 65th Brendan Bell (GP: 48-80tax= -32)
- 82nd Jay Harrison (GP: 13-80tax= -67)
- 88th Nicolas Corbeil (GP: 0-80tax= -80)
- 134th Kyle Wellwood (GP: 166 no tax)
- 168th Maxim Kondratiev (GP 40 no tax)
- 183rd Jaroslav Sklenar (GP 0 no tax)
- 198th Iva Kolozvary (GP 0 no tax)
- 213th Jan Chovan (GP 0 no tax)
- 246th Tomas Mojzis (GP 13 no tax)
- 276th Mike Knoepfil (GP 0 no tax)
I think everyone associated with this draft has been fired. I should point out that injury has affected their draft but that goes for all teams and certainly affected the Oilers in the case of Doug Lynch.
Okay a few points and then I would like to ask you some questions (if you’ve read this far please keep going). Based on this one season I would say the Oilers draft department did well but could have done better. I would put them in the mid-level area with Vancouver. Of course the cream of the crop on this list is Ottawa, with Montreal off the pace of the mid-level teams, plus Calgary Toronto in trouble. The Leafs would have a very nice draft the following season, although I haven’t put it through this “tax system” I’m looking at here.
Okay, some questions for you.
- Does this kind of system tell us anything we wouldn’t know just by adding up the GP?
- Does it tell us anything worth knowing?
- Is the tax system a fair one? If not, where could it be improved?
- Should we give special consideration for players who are clearly at a level above the rest?
- Could we use this over a 25-year period without changing the tax?
- Any other ways to improve the system?
As an aside, the Habs draft is on display right now on HNIC if you didn’t know.
EDIT TO ADD: Fixed the Calgary Moss mistake, thanks to toqueboy for catching it.