Game 9 2023-24: Stars at Oilers

by Lowetide
Photo by Connor Mah

The Edmonton Oilers had a strong game versus the Calgary Flames and it appears several elements of the team’s game have settled in. The top two lines, the defense and Stuart Skinner look like they can deliver a quality (and repeatable) performance. The Dallas Stars beat the Flames last night and will play the second of a back-to-back this evening at Rogers. Important game. Hurry sundown.

THE ATHLETIC!

WHAT TO EXPECT IN NOVEMBER

  • At home to: DAL, NAS (Expected 1-1-0) (Actual 0-0-0)
  • On the road to: VAN, SJS, SEA (Expected 1-1-1) (Actual 0-0-0)
  • At home to: NYI, SEA (Expected 2-0-0) (Actual 0-0-0)
  • On the road to: TBY, FLA, CAR, WAS (Expected 1-3-0) (Actual 0-0-0)
  • At home to: ANA, VEG (Expected 1-1-0) (Actual 0-0-0)
  • On the road to: WPG (Expected 1-0-0) (Actual 0-0-0)
  • Overall expected result: 7-6-1, 15 points in 14 games
  • Actual November results: 0-0-0, 0 points in 0 games
  • Oilers in 2023-24: 2-5-1, 5 points in 8 games

I don’t trust this team as far as I can throw it, so a .500 month seems right from here. There is a window for a good streak of wins, I think the first six games offer a real opportunity. That road trip to the southeast, though. Will the Kraken do to the Oilers what the Canucks did in October?

LINES AND PAIRINGS

  • McDavid-Draisaitl-Foegele
  • Kane-Nuge-Hyman
  • Holloway-McLeod-Brown
  • Ryan-Gagner
  • Nurse-Ceci
  • Ekholm-Bouchard
  • Kulak-Desharnais/Broberg
  • Skinner (Campbell)

I have no idea how they’ll run Sam Gagner but it does matter. The third line is trash right now offensively. He could provide a spark if he gets there.

I’m down on this team.

I know Connor McDavid, Mattias Ekholm and Ryan McLeod will get completely healthy and 97 will carry the weight, but you see that’s the problem. Vegas Golden Knights built a better mousetrap. The Oilers aren’t trying to get better now, they’re waiting until the deadline to swing deals.

Sam Pollock used to have Scotty Bowman play the kids early in the year to see if they could improve. If they did, come spring time they would be on the playoff roster. Those who were expendable got dealt for Frank Mahovlich, and many players with flaws (Yvon Lambert’s foot speed could be timed by sundial) found work with the Habs.

It can be done.

Ken Holland is having Jay Woodcroft play the veterans over the kids and so we already know the answer next spring. Dylan Holloway, Philip Broberg and Raphael Lavoie need to play. Otherwise they’re going to be as they are next spring. To everything there is a season. A time to plant, a time to reap. A time to every purpose under Heaven.

Except in Edmonton.

This is a huge game and we’ll cover it wall to wall on the Lowdown, noon-2pm on Sports 1440. Bagged Milk from Oilers Nation will join us and we’ll also chat World Series and the marvel of the Texas Rangers. You can reach me in the comments section, @Lowetide on twitter, or text us 1.833.401.1440 directly.

You may also like

4.5 8 votes
Article Rating
331 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Scungilli Slushy

The Oilers may have great fancies on xG and HD chances, but those can be misleading. I didn’t see many actually dangerous offensive plays for a team with this much skill, and haven’t. Even on PP. The danger there was only Bouch’s shot, which is not stoppable if he hits between the pipes. Sam’s first one was will more than skill

And as we saw top cheddar is far more likely to score than all of the ‘in the breadbasket’ and ‘another pad save – he didn’t have to move much on that one’, ‘missed that one by a foot’ the others manage

So every goalie is Tretiak it seems when we play them. I think it’s more that they make 40 routine saves, and Bouch is the only Oiler that shoots for the top of the net regularly

Including Drai and his one shot that isn’t working right now. And our goalie sucks because he is facing a lot of very dangerous plays, and isn’t being Tretiak to bail their befuddled butts out

Reja

I for one believe our best prospects Malone and Griffith have been marinating in Kenny’s secret barbecue sauce long
enough. It’s time to give these young lads a cup of coffee and see what we have brewing for the future.

Last edited 10 months ago by Reja
GordieHoweHatTrick

I am glad the Oilers played Gagner to show the others what playing with some emotion and heart is all about. I see him, Kane (lately), Desharnais (usually) as the few playing with some emotion. Anyone see others?

Time to make some logical moves.
Enough of this 7 D bullshit. Send Broberg down to get more ice time and find a rhythm until he makes a very strong case to come back up. Bring up a 7 D to sit in the press box. Send Brown down for “conditioning” (no one is going to claim him) and if he can’t make a case for coming back up in a month or so, save the team cap hell next year. Bring up Lavoie for top 9. Bring up a fire plug for the 4th line. IT really isn’t that complicated.

innercitysmytty

Add Foegele to the list of players consistently playing with emotion. Agreed on the 7D – it’s had it’s time and place and is not working right now.

GordieHoweHatTrick

This team needs an enema.

Chelios is a Dinosaur

You win that game 4/7, and against a good team. They were on a back to back, should have been able to fire the kill shot. A better bottom 6 effort them there, a healthy McDavid wins that game probably. Leon also looks off.

Alas I knew when they started Oettinger in Calgary this was going to mean trouble. Do we have data on backups’ save % against Oilers?

Reja

When Sir Holland returns from his African Safari trip with Bowman he has to fire Woody who has run out of ideas and motivation. There’s still delusional fans that think we can still catch Vegas when Kenny finally gets us a new coach this team will get the much needed. dead cat bounce.

PinkSocks

Well at least the defensive blunders have moved from the defensive zone to on the rush. You’d like a goalie to make a save for you, but losing that game was just poor luck, nothing else. Also #97 isn’t healthy.

Decidedly Skeptical Fan

With Brown injured, I’m thinking Kenny is probably on the phone with Stevie to see what might be available. Kostin would be nice, but not if it’s an overpay, which it will be. I’m guessing something truly terrible like Kostin and future considerations for Ryan, Lavoie and a pair of 2nd round picks. Right in Kenny’s wheelhouse.

PinkSocks

Kostin has the same number of goals as the rest of the Oiler’s bottom six. Two less than Sam Gagner.

OriginalPouzar

He has not been on for a GF this season and makes $2MM X 2, I believe.

Decidedly Skeptical Fan

Didn’t realize it till tonight but prior to playing last season for WPG, Gagner played the prior three seasons for … wait for it … Detroit. Gotta love Kenny.

Android

Holland was the one who traded him there for Athanasiou.

Android

Holland was actually the one who traded him to Detroit for Athanasiou.

iwin76

Send Broberg down if necessary, Janmark and/or Brown to LTIR. Brown especially, rest and then practice for a while to get up to speed for real.

Hyman-McDavid-Holloway
Kane-Draisatl-Gagner
Foegele-Nuge-Lavoie
Bourgalt-Mcleod-Ryan

D is whatever. If Desharnais had more speed I’d say try a shutdown pair with Ekholm and let Bouchard have easier matchups with Kulak, but not sure that would work. Stuck with Nurse-Ceci I think.

Oddly, Oilers lead the league in xGF% on Natural Stattrick. Soft schedule and score effects contribute I’m sure. But they need a goalie. Fingers crossed Campbell can find a hot streak. Or honestly, waive one of them and give Pickard/Rodrigue a shot, they’ve been solid (based on stats, I have not watched).

Harpers Hair

No mention of Connor Brown leaving with a lower body injury in his 9th game of the season?

Could be a blessing.

Decidedly Skeptical Fan

It would be inexcusable for Kenny to leave the next GM with that cap hit. Full stop.

iwin76

There isn’t much doubt a stint for him on LTIR would benefit the team. Good fancies or not, in the word’s of MacT, you at least have to be a threat to score… and I haven’t seen much.

CrazyCoach

Just seeing the highlights now and well, enjoy those two goals from Gagner, because he always will regress to the mean and the mean sucks.

Meanwhile another 23 year old scoring forward will quietly do a slow burn in Bakersfield and when his contract is up, he will bolt for another team and I won’t blame him one bit.

This team either a) brings kids up way too early and then do not develop them or b) Let them rot in the minors and give up on them or trade them for peanuts.

Once again, I’m glad I paid for coaching courses and my league fees for playing over Sportsnet+

striker

So…goaltending, am I right?

Last edited 10 months ago by striker
LMHF#1

No.

Play 60 instead of 10.

Score 5 like you should.

Win.

97, 29 and the powerplay were absent tonight. That’s what cost them.

samIam

The goaltending is not good by any measure. Defense measures ok, but the magnitude of the mistakes is massive. D are still the primary problem. Goalies are not covering for their massive mistakes.

Last edited 10 months ago by samIam
Kurri17

Well, goaltending may not have been the primary culprit, but ONCE AGAIN, the Oilers had the inferior goalie of the night. Got goalied by Wedgewood, while Skinner sported yet another sub .900 performance. Oilers had almost 50 shots, Stars scored 4 on 27. Enough said.

SayItAin'tSo, Gretz, SayItAin'tSo!

Stu was lamer than lame on that Duchene goal. And the looks skyward is getting boring.

A solid first period from the goaltending tandem would help quite a bit.

Kurri17

Every defensive breakdown ends up in the Oilers’ net. Frankly, I’m ready to throw Campbell back in there for another go again since we can’t change out 4 defensemen.

innercitysmytty

Yep. Pretty amazing how few will admit most of our issues stem from not getting enough saves. Of course, we get goalied by a backup. Our goalies rarely win a game for us. Must be nice.

Last edited 10 months ago by innercitysmytty
winchester

Gagner shows up and he is not infected by fancy-pants hockey. As wonderful as our top players are, those pretty goals cannot be the only way to score. We need the messy goals, the ugly goals.

The shots were absolutely there tonight.
Need to pick up the garbage goals.

Oilers got the skill players, they have the speed players, they are short on the hard nose grinders.

thelongdark

Too many fancy Dan’s!

Kurri17

Winners win and losers lose. Sam Gagner showing all the others how to score in the NHL; no overpassing, overthinking and looking for the perfect play. Just take it right to the net.

Funny Bissonness

I think it’s time for a moment of silence for the 2023-24 San Jose Sharks.

Kurri17

And for the 2023-2024 Oilers.

Harpers Hair

They are working on their 16th straight loss going back to last season.

samIam

They could be the worst team of all time. But amazingly have better goaltending than Edmonton. I wonder if a trade for Blackwood is possible.

SKOilerFan

PP needs a redraw. It’s well scouted.
No way it should go 0 for 4 against a tired team like that
93, 29, 18 not getting enough done with all their ice time

Foege Foegele Torpe

Stars were 1 for 2 on the PP?
special teams are pretty pedestrian

Scungilli Slushy

I have said for ages they need counter strategies. It is so obvious especially when they really need a goal. Set up Leon, or Bouch now. Aren’t there 3 other players?

scratchybeard

This team is broken. Watching the Canucks play like we should makes me sad. They have heart, hustle and a will to win. My how far we have fallen. Time to change the coach and get some fire back in their bellies.

Foege Foegele Torpe

Not broken, just playing like assholes.
I’m sure it’s still a playoff team but it’s getting late early

Scungilli Slushy

Solutions as I see it to do now

Ice Kenny. No need to embarrass him but someone else managing. Jackson must know how to make deals. They won’t happen short term but there is a lot that could be done to make this season what is wanted

If Battman will reinstate Quenneville you do it now. I believe he can handle this group and use the pieces in place far better

The energy level is far too low. The emotional level is too low. PK is not a personnel issue, it’s a coaching issue, repeatedly for us

PinkSocks

Quenneville quite literally did nothing about a young man being sexually abused by a member of his staff, he knew about it, swept it under the rug, and fkd up a 19-year old’s life and career. Good coach or not, hiring a person possessing a moral compass of such a nature is inexcusable.

meanashell11

Completely agree.

KnightRain

We’ve been bitten by the snake, again…it’s ridiculous the chances we’ve blown but they’re gonna start going in. We just have to keep at it , work our asses off and not overthink things, like what Connor and Leon seem to be doing.
Gagner may not have the boots anymore but he knows how much effort it takes to win. I, for one, hope he sticks around. The whole team can learn for watching him do everything he can out there.

Scungilli Slushy

Agreed I hope he can keep it up. First games he will

teddyturnbuckle

The Good. Sam Gagner with a great effort. Evander Kane had a good game. I thought Vinny was involved, jumped up into the play once. Holloway had some jump.

The Bad. McDavid and Draisatl need to be split up again. Both are skating around the perimeter not creating much. Skinner didn’t come up with a big save and like every game the Oilers were outplayed in goal. Ekholm is not playing well. Broberg is bringing nothing to the team, maybe send him down and call up another player. Nuge had a few points but I didn’t like his game.

Scungilli Slushy

For me the problem is that some players get points but do nothing else for most of the rest of their time

Pushing every shift is important for the overall play

Points matter but a shit ton of points and personal bests and records and mosts lead to nothing last season

This game was a shit show again. The coach didn’t use his hottest player end of game

SKOilerFan

Makes a guy wonder if 89 was brought in to address some dressing room or leadership issues.
Defending takes team buy in. It’s not there consistently enough. Exhibit A – Broberg flubs the dump and the forwards couldn’t get off soon enough to avoid the minus. Maybe consider bailing your rookie D out then give him crap later?
89 addressed some on ice issues anyway.

Scungilli Slushy

If you think of how bad the team was when Sam was key and that they need him now to get them up now, it makes me sad

winchester

Gagner has some heart. Love it.

Sierra

50% on the PK
0% on the PP
0 points from the bottom 6 except for old man Sam
2 GA on terrible mistakes/breakdowns.

this team is not good right now

godot10

Ceci on the first and third goals.
Broberg on the 2nd goal
Bouchard on the 4th goal.

All four goals against were pretty bad mistakes or bad coverage.

winchester

Desharnais is making the safe plays. But he is showing up as a steady Eddie and solidifying his importance to the team.

thelongdark

Happy for Samwise.

But no moral victories. Need wins.

Oddspell

Another loss to add to the pile, but somehow that near comeback was more encouraging than the blowout against Nashville or the outdoor win over Calgary. Those 15 minutes felt like a hungry team for the first time this entire year. I’ll take that scrappy 15 minutes over squeaking out an undeserved 2 points.

Last edited 10 months ago by Oddspell
godot10

Are we supposed to get excited about an Oiler team playing well in the last 10 minutes of a game where the opposition was playing the 3rd game in 4 nights, and back-to-back?

Harpers Hair

And backup goaltender.

KnightRain

Gagner scored two goals off of pure effort and determination. He didn’t try for a highlight. He just got the puck to the net and went to the scoring area, hard.
I hope our guys take note of this. Hockey is hard. Scoring is hard. Go hard.

SayItAin'tSo, Gretz, SayItAin'tSo!

Gonna be a solid run now.

Defensemen really need to stop spotting goals. The Ceci, Broberg and Bouchard against the Rags were spotting goals. No more of that.

More shots for McLeon please. No more passing, more shots. More shots at 5v5, more shots on PP.

Bouchard is going to score 100.

Scungilli Slushy

Drai one timer leaks out of the zone as usual. Really?

Darryl8843

Are we still doing morale victories? That was a beauty

LMHF#1

Too little too late.

Show up for 60.

Scungilli Slushy

I would make almost every forward watch tape of Bedard practicing shots and make them stay late at practice. None are bottom net

Get some confidence guys and shoot like you mean to score

Sierra

It is not reasonable to expect bottom 6 forwards to shoot like Bedard. Instead the coaches have to figure out how to get the best out of each player, whether it’s shooting more, shooting high or crashing the net.

Scungilli Slushy

How about top 6?

LMHF#1

No Gagner 6-on-5 is a mistake.

Scungilli Slushy

So Woody. Bullshit

Scungilli Slushy

Kane is sloppy but he knows how goals are scored

SKOilerFan

There’s 3 forwards that came to play tonight and one of them can’t finish.
Sad

teddyturnbuckle

McDavid and Draisaitl can’t get anything done tonight.

SKOilerFan

What in the actual F as that Dria? Blind spinarama pass to no one. Sit that guy. Fin 89 twice the player right now

Kurri17

Sam Gagner showing the entire bottom 6 who their daddy is.

813.52Ran

And most of the top 6.

Darryl8843

Why in hell is Sam the hardest working player? Atta be Sammy

CrazyCoach

My washing machine works hard, but it’s not going to lead this team out of the basement.

Prairie_Sentinel

You just love to see it

KnightRain

BOOM!!! Gags with another ugly goal!!! You can’t make this stuff up!!

KnightRain

What great moves by Kaner!!!

LMHF#1

Kane and Gagner.

There’s some fire there.

oilinthepeg

LOLOLOL

Gerta Rauss

Gagner could get 8 tonight at this rate

KnightRain

Gags on the second line! You gotta admit, he makes things happen out there.

Scungilli Slushy

Sam said his hips feel best in years, and his skating is looking ok

It was never great, but good for him. The heart is there, and that matters to a degree

Maybe inject some Oiler passion into these guys

Darryl8843

So in less than 3 periods Gagne has one more goal than the entire bottom 6 this year. What more needs to be said

oilinthepeg

Haha! Well, seems like we are in ‘moral victories’ territory this game, so I’ll take a Gags goal! Woo!

Scungilli Slushy

Who called it? Reja?