TMI ON TOI?

by Lowetide
  • Noah Philp .55
  • Matvey Petrov .46
  • Matthew Savoie .44
  • Jayden Grubbe .28

You may also like

4.4 11 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
31 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
NovaScotiaOiler

Apart from a duly noted exception of occasionally getting to watch (and skate with!) the Nova Scotia Oilers back when I was 8 and 9, I had very little awareness of the Oilers prospect pool until I discovered this blog. I was always just a turn on the TV and root for the team on the ice, kinda guy

Through this site I’ve developed a whole new layer of knowledge and appreciation for this team and I love coming here daily to find LTs thoughtful statistical analysis on players and prospects, Tarkus’ regular prospectivus reporting on all our draft picks, OP’s live updates on the Condors and everyone else who takes time out of their day to regularly contribute their insights and opinions – be they contrarian or otherwise.

So thank you again LT for gifting us this special corner of the internet to learn, debate and commune as fans. And a shoutout to Tarkus, OP and everyone who contributes here daily to make this the place it is. I’m not much of a poster myself, so thought I’d at least offer my gratitude.

Merry Christmas and happy holiday everyone!

OriginalPouzar

Appreciate that – happy holidays!

fishman

Well said! Merry Christmas to all as well!

OriginalPouzar

For those who are concerned about Matthew Savoie, and there are some, Dylan Holloway posted a .30 points-game at even strength age 20 with the Condors. Savoie is a terrific prospect doing good things at a young age as a new pro.

It also should be mentioned that 20-year old rookie pros often struggle early and perform better in the 2nd half of the year – we should expect a strong second half from Savoie.

He’s also the type of player, in my opinion, that will produce even more at the NHL level playing with smart and skilled players that he can make plays with. Savoie doesn’t seem to like hanging on to the puck a ton – his game is about smart and skilled quick plays with the puck.

lenko

Maybe they won’t drag their heels with him. Seems guys you root for end up somewhere else and end up doing great.

OriginalPouzar

He’s still 20 (for another week) and on the first year of his ELC.

The Oilers have been a top 2 team in the league since end of October and likely want to move a forward off the roster (to get 7D active) at some point. He’s not breaking to door down to get a call-up so, for now, I’d continue to allow him to develop – I would say they are a long ways from dragging heels.

Scungilli Slushy

Like many small players with skill it will depend on how he can translate his talents to the hardest league. It’s a tall mountain few climb for long. Of course I hope he’s a star

OriginalPouzar

Petrov really struggled early in the year offensively. We know he wasn’t in great shape for camp. There may be a bit of context there as, yesterday, Chaulk mentioned that he was hurt last year and didn’t have a full summer. Perhaps that was part of the reason for not being in great shape but, either way, he struggled at prospects camp, main camp, AHL camp and early in the season.

Of course, he is on fire offensively now, often scoring with that shot of his and has really settled in on a line with Grubbe (who is playing great) and Cam Wright.

All of his production is at 5 on 5 as well and I’d like to see him get a bump on to PP1 over Griffith or Caggiula or Pederson. Savoie is a staple on PP1.

It should also be mentioned that Petrov is a very responsible 2-way player and has been since his last year in North Bay.

This pop is maybe 3-4 weeks long so we’ll see if its a real pop or a heater but he’s put his name back in the conversation.

TravisTDK

Thanks for adding to LT post. I don’t watch prospects just pay attention to stats but it feels like there might be a bit of optimism for Petrov.

dcsj

getting ready to head up island for family get together, may not check in here too much the next couple of days. Just want to express my thanks to LT for this site and the careful attention to the whole team, especially the prospects. I love getting to know their stories and I wish they could all make it (though my rational side knows some will miss). It makes following the team all the more interesting to me. Cheering for the guys on the fringes!

cowboy bill

I’d like to send a shout out to the Edmonton Oiler players like (Podkolzin, Kapanen, Janmark, Henrique, Brown, Arvidsson, Perry & Ryan) plus guys like Kulak, Emberson, Stecher & both goaltenders who don’t get enough credit for this team’s success. They are the platoon that
truly make it happen.

Last edited 10 hours ago by cowboy bill
John Chambers

Evander Kane for Chris Kreider?
Discuss

BornInAGretzkyJersey

It would definitely add some speed to the line up. And probably more goals given sh%.

NHL Edge data for last season (because Kane hasn’t played yet this year, and sample size):
CK – https://edge.nhl.com/en/skater/20232024-regular-8475184
EK – https://edge.nhl.com/en/skater/20232024-regular-8475169

Age is the same.

NYR would have to be enticed to retain about $1.5MM in salary for this year and next.

And then, there’s the pesky detail of both players having NMC provisions on their contracts.

Could certainly be an upgrade, but seems unlikely.

cowboy bill

They’re both UFA’s next season and aging power forwards. I didn’t realize Kane is UFA next season, it should be a big motivation for him to get back and playing ASAP. I don’t see the rangers making this trade, Kreider is healthy and ready to go. He’s also a $6.50M cap hit.

ArmchairGM

Jeff Skinner regularly outscores Kreider at 5v5. And he’s cheaper, and not signed for 2 more years.

The only upside Kreider has over Kane is his current health status. He’d be a downgrade otherwise.

Last edited 8 hours ago by ArmchairGM
cowboy bill

My mistake, I thought he was UFA next season. I would have to say though Kreider would certainly be an upgrade on Jeff Skinner. Kane still remains a mystery. There’s no telling what sort of a player Kane will be when healthy.
He’s like a box of chocolates.

Last edited 8 hours ago by cowboy bill
John Chambers

I love Kane when he’s healthy and ferocious. No telling what kind of player we’re getting back after surgery, but I’m tempering expectations.

Kreider on the other hand is an elite power forward who’s competitive as hell and has a track record of good health.

Good health being key. I’d bet on Kreider as opposed to Kane to offer more come playoff time.

cowboy bill

Exactly. So, why would the rangers make this trade?
AND why are we even talking about this?

Last edited 7 hours ago by cowboy bill
Side

Kreider was a healthy scratch yesterday and has 6 even strength points so far this season. In a season where he’s not doing well and the Rangers are imploding, organizations can do some drastic things.

The Rangers traded their captain already, so why not their longest tenured player?

John Chambers

It’s a buy-low opportunity on a player whose a proven playoff performer.
Nothing more nothing less.

cowboy bill

For Evander Kane?

Side

Not really supporting the trade one way or another as I haven’t followed Kreider much.

I did find it interesting that he was healthy scratched yesterday and I didn’t realize how poorly he was doing up until that point. Was mostly sharing what I learned that could answer the “why would the Rangers trade him?” part.

John Chambers

There is no comparison between Chris Kreider and Jeff Skinner. One is a 5’11” perimeter player (a fancy Dan), while the other is a 6’3” 230 linebacker on skates.
Who do you prefer lining up for us in the playoffs?

ArmchairGM

Evander Kane.

You (and a lot of other Oilers fans) have already written off Jeff Skinner, but he’s producing nearly 3x the points at 5v5 as Kreider is (1.49 v 0.54 P/60) this season. He outscored Kreider last year and the year before too, so it’s not a short term trend.

If the contracts were equal I wouldn’t be against giving Kreider a shot here, but $3M x 1 is a lot different than $6.5M x 3. Kreider is certainly more physical than Skinner, but sometimes that takes a toll and at 33 he appears to have headed off the proverbial cliff.

Tarkus

Birds of Fire making news!

First, as reported yesterday, Clattenburg signing his ELC.

And now, Day being named OHL Goaltender of the Week. Second time he has been so honoured.

Scungilli Slushy

If Clattenburg develops a rounded enough game he will get a push I think, not for his offense. Rare bird in the org

Glad for Petrov. He seems to have an NHL tool kit, love the shot, hope he can keep going. OP says his defensive play is good, I imagine it will come down to whether he wants to play in front enough. He has the size. He seems like the type of winger Dallas would develop into an NHL player

cowboy bill

Petrov is starting to sound like the type of winger Leon likes to play with.

cowboy bill

Connor Clattenburg reminds me of a young Kelly Buchburger. Who eventually became an Oiler captain. Not sure Clattenburg has Buchberger’s speed, but he certainly has his toughness and desire to succeed.

Reja

How about a cross between Buchburger and Curt Brakenbury.

cowboy bill

Curt Brackenbury hardly had the distinguished career of Kelly Buchburger. I hope he isn’t a Brackenbury comparable for his sake. I have higher expectations and so should Connor Clattenburg.

31
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x