The Edmonton Oilers have been enjoying the Pacific Division pillow soft opposition so far this season, but the three-game road trip to New York should offer a stiffer test. Edmonton’s top line and pairing are absolute money, but what about the rest of the roster? Please read this.
WHAT TO EXPECT IN OCTOBER
- At home to: Vancouver (Expected 1-0) Actual 0-0-1
- On the road: Vancouver (Expected 1-0) Actual 1-0-0
- At home to: Seattle (Expected 1-0) Actual 1-0-0
- On the road to: Anaheim, San Jose, Los Angeles (1-1-1) Actual 3-0-0
- At home to: Mammoth (1-0) Actual 0-1-0
- On the road to: Mammoth (0-0-1) Actual 1-0-0
- At home to: Minnesota, Carolina, Toronto, Detroit, Calgary (3-2) Actual 3-1-1
- On the road to: New York Islanders (1-0)
- Expected Record: 9-3-2, 20 points in 14 games
- Actual Record: 9-2-2, 20 points in 13 games
The Oilers have already covered my bet on them, so we are dealing with house money this afternoon. Edmonton doesn’t traditionally perform well in these afternoon games, and Babcock doesn’t know that yet. The New York Islanders are a team with an incredible amount of age, with an elite young defenseman who just turned 19 and some goaltending witchcraft. I have the game as a win for the road team, your mileage may vary.
HOW TO IMPROVE?
The good thing about Babcock’s Oilers? The win-loss the record, followed by obvious areas to improve. People are hammering Jake Walman currently, and rightly so, he’s been awful. That said, we’ve seen him playing well and now he needs to get back to that place.
Some of the lines on this team haven’t played well and were still jumping over the boards as of earlier this week. As we know Babcock hates losing, suspect we will see more adds and subtractions as the season wears along. He has made some tweaks, and they show promise; here are the five-on-five numbers by line currently:
- Podkolzin-McDavid-Draisaitl: 164 mins, 73 pct goal share, 2.19GA-60 2.85 XGA-60
- Dach-Nuge-Kapanen: 20 mins, 100 pct goal share, 0 GA-60, 1.31 XGA-60
- Formenton-Dickinson-Joseph: 12 mins, 100 pct goal share, 0 GA-60, 2.43 XGA-60
- Howard-Michaels-Frederic: 18 mins, 0 goal share 0GA-60, 2.43 XGA-60
This is the new alignment, trashing the Michaels line with Formenton and Joseph. That trio played 100 minutes together, 36 percent goal share, 5.34 GA-60 and 2.99 XGA-60. So, yeah. Babcock doesn’t like to lose and either by gut or by golly this group is going to improve. I like Michaels, think he might need some time in Bakersfield. On the other hand, the new fourth line looks fine early days.
The defense has three guys (Ekholm, Bouchard, Shea) who are diamonds, two guys (Murphy, Emberson) who are adequate and one old chunk of coal (Walman). Who was the last NHL defenseman making $7 million to spend several years on the farm? Wade Redden? The Oilers have some real talent on LD in Bakersfield (Damien Carfagna and Tomas Cibulka) so the pressure is on Walman. I don’t have a solution, but if the coach isn’t playing Walman and the Condors reports are strong on the youngsters, what is stopping the team from making that move? Babcock is impatient. That isn’t a bad thing.


Does Edmonton Oilers rookie Owen Michaels need time in the minors?
https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7734123/2026/10/31/edmonton-oilers-owen-michaels-rookie-stats-2026/
Wild stuff here. Babcock hockey.
Dellow and Cory Sznajer were pioneers with the All Three Zones project. This was a sentinel project that showed controlled entries led to twice as many unblocked shot attempts as dump ins.
What’s interesting, is do controlled entry attempts come at a cost in neutral zone with more turnovers and rush chances against?
Babcock is kicking it old school here. Also, your stick’s gotta be a crowbar.
https://x.com/MikeKellyNHL/status/2116197872446456280?a=ytYwAJIk8thc0WP0K2A&s=20
For those not on X.
Look at Edmonton’s 5v5 rankings from last season to this season:
Babcock’s strategy reminds me of the ancient Chinese story of Tian Ji’s three horses. You don’t need to win every matchup to win the contest.
Edmonton’s formula is simple:
The increased dump-ins, emphasis on puck battles and dramatic reduction in rush chances against all fit that philosophy.
The bottom three lines don’t need to win the expected-goals battle. They need to prevent opponents from building leads against Edmonton’s weaker players, then shutting things down against McDavid.
Win with your strengths. Neutralize your weaknesses.
A lot of the conclusions of public analytics turn out to be misleading.As Brian Burke has often said on Stauffer’s show, they are “a lamp post to a drunk,” with drunks looking for keys, where the lights are.
Did they count puck battle win percentage? Did they count odd man rushes?
Did they measure zone time?
More than dump in rate and controlled entry rate, the key seems to be the decisions made when entering the zone: its the quality of the dump and the quality of controlled entry that matters.
As pointed out by Curlock, Edmonton turns out very good when playing the cycle rather than trying forcing the rush, which is a direct function of the quality of the entries and choices they are making, either by dump or controlled entry.
Knoblauch, an analytics coach, was not capable of seeing this and kept looking for keys where the light was. He did not address the choices of star players to force a controlled entry even when it was a low percentage play. Or he saw the issue and was unable to convince his players to make more judicious choices due to lack of “gravitas”.
In Kelly’s video from earlier this year he shows the change in dump in rate for various players.
There are players who are more successful on controlled entries – and even McDavid who is still the most successful Oiler at controlled entries, has been more judicious with his choices.
https://x.com/MikeKellyNHL/status/2110832801683521629?a=f9Ji2VweCT4qNwtybAE&s=20
You have line that is massively outscoring, the other lines are incapable of playing their style so why get them to try. Have them play a low event wear the opponent down style. I guess you could use the old style war comp of light cavalry deployed differently than foot soldiers
Diversified attack
If you’re always dumping their D is goingback on the retrieval early
If you’re always rushing their D will stand up with tight gaps and create turnovers at the worst spot
Pretty simple flow chart – asses your odds of entry on the rush. Less than 80% then dump?
Now repeat the study focusing only on the playoffs. Now repeat the study focusing only on teams who make the Stanley Cup finals.
i.e. Stratify the data. All hockey games and all hockey teams are NOT equal.
Babcock wants to eliminate chances, particularly outnumbered chances, against, and to create turnovers near the Oilers offensive blueline.
The best offensive strategy may NOT be the optimum strategy for winning.
Babcock wants low variance hockey. Then the creators of high variance, McDavid, Draisaitl, and Bouchard become the determining factor.
Summarizing!
Harvey finally got off the schneid with his 3rd goal of the year — a shortie, no less — and picked up an aPPle.
Wakely garnered a helper.
Lewandowski incurred no soup but did sewer his chances of winning the WHL Most Sportsmanlike Player of the Year by racking up 16 PIM’s.
Park (who finally returned to the lineup), Barnett, Berry, and Fischer similarly were held soupless.
Cameron once again watched from the bench. Has he played himself out of the starting role?
Robinson missed his 3rd straight game.
Did OP get put in the penalty box?
Nice to see new faces around here
three Scoring lines? If Dach and Nuge keep this up this looks like a pretty good option to me.
Savoie-McD-Hyman
Podz-Drai-Kapanen
Dach-Nuge-Joseph
You guys have to stop with the Nuge is a 3rd liner shtick. He has 7 points including three goals in 5 games.
could be the best 2C in the league. still not better than Drai dropped to 2C.
Drai is taking more faceoffs then McDavid on the top line. So either McDavid or Draisaitl is also the best winger in the league while Nuge is covering the 2C hole with perfection so far.
Yes. This we know.
just saying a strong 3line involving Nuge is no indictment of his abilities. it’s simply an option Oil would be lucky to have.
Canes won the cup with Hall/Ehlers on the “third line”.
The idea with this type of deployment is to outscore from the bottom six, forcing opposing coaches to adjust, which in turn creates softer matchups for the 97 and 29 lines.
yup.
Who had Jarry posting back-to-back shut-outs on their Bingo card?
Oilers somehow still have a perfect record on the road. Only team without a road loss.
Hopefully Howard is ok. Knee injuries are no joke.
Babcock said his knee doesnt seem as bad as they initially thought. They’re going to rest him tomorrow and see where it’s at
Babcock on Nuge
He’s a real hockey player…he’s beyond smart, makes the right plays all the time
Thank you for picking up OP’s slack.
(Hoping he is just taking a break and not in a hospital somewhere)
I see he’s posting at ON today – he’ll be OK
Sometimes taking a break is good for all parties concerned
Babcock on Isaac Howard injury
“We don’t think it’s as serious as we first thought…we’re hoping for a real good kind of recovery day for him tomorrow, and then if he doesn’t, we’ll get on with the medical part of looking into it, but they think it’s favourable”
-post game presser via Oilers website
Report from UBS Arena, where I did not get beat up, but caught non-trivial volumes of stink-eye:
Janky game, not much flow.
Schaefer really is something to see-just an effortless skater. The times he matched up against 97 were the best parts of the game.
The ice-clearing crew in Halloween Jason masks was a nice touch, same with the Zamboni shaped like a Heineken six-pack.
Frederic is fortunate to be tall and wealthy, because I have growing concerns he is not so bright.
I didn’t win the 50/50, which is clearly rigged.
Dude a few rows behind us was cheering hard for the Oilers. When Draisaitl was ragging the puck in the o-zone, dude hollered, “Oh, he’s so strong! He’s so handsome!” Then when Islanders fans started saying Jarry sucks dude hollered “He’s good enough!”
Overall, better fan experience at the Islanders rink than the Rangers; MSG is lousy with suits and vest-clad finance bros, the Islanders faithful are true hockey fans. You should have heard the guy two rows in front of me cuss out the ref, I feared the zebra was going to spontaneously combust.
How on earth does this get a down vote?
Unfortunately this seems to be a common occurrence??
Vest-wearing finance bro Rangers fan paid for a bot to downvote any posts that undermine their otherwise triumphant narrative?
Awesome game report!
Are you taking in the next two games in greater NYC?
Who starts in net tomorrow?
Babcock confirmed Tomkins going tomorrow.
Thanks.
Obviously we’d rather have Levi or Andersen, but Tomkins isn’t a terrible option for a fourth string goalie.
Agreed. I was hoping for Jarry again as although its a b2b, with the early game today and low workload, I figured it was still safe to keep him going but hard to blame them for prioritizing his health given their other injuries currently.
RNH looking great at 2C. Keep it up and my off season predictions are going to start sounding silly.
Solid, solid game from the Oilers, entire team effort. Great to see the scoring spread out, Jarry playing well and the 3rd pairing being dependable.
I don’t think it’s a coincidence that following a shit-kicking from TO and poor game against DET, the Oilers responded with two highly disciplined shutouts. It tracks.
#neverindoubt
(Actually though)
After his first few games, I didn’t think I’d be watching Mookie again any time soon, let alone seeing some good things from him.
Clutterbuck looking like Eeyore in the post game segment. Aw shucks.
2026 Oilers- defensive juggernaut’s!
Jarry could’ve won that one In a rocking chair.
NYI is clearly not good – but the D was still on point.
Wish the attack was more ruthless. If anything holds them back from setting some records this year, it will be games like that where you just don’t have the drive that the Gretzky-led teams had.
Surprise Barzal is injured again. The list is getting lengthy for him and he’s not yet 30.
He hasn’t played a game yet this season, and also missed training camp. Left knee injury (probably still dealing with the broken kneecap from last season) and the Isles reported earlier today there is no change in his status, still “skating on his own”. It is a shame for the player like you said..
Just looked it up – inflammation problems remaining from surgery. Yikes.
So many positives, Jarry, depth scoring, solid third pairing.
Cock’s Oilers are a wagon.
That’ll do.
Jarry hasn’t allowed a goal in 126:47.
Back to back shutouts.
Back to back shut outs by Jarry!!!! Who called that????
Bah, he’s no Scrivens
Joseph and Kapanen both keeping up a healthy .5 ppg
Those “grab” holding penalties are so bad. They often do a great job of showing who’s an unintelligent hockey player.
Another questionable call.
Gotta kill the final two minutes.
Maybe they should 4-0 all the time.
Thank you Jason Dickinson for demonstrating proper EN technique.
It’s a skill.
Nice workmanlike 3rd period by the Oil
And give Jarry his due, back to back shut outs is pretty great.
Sorokin has kept them in the game. Kinda.
Nice ENG.
DickinsEN goal
Mattias Ekholm is one of the most reliable PKing defensemen I’ve ever seen.
So if Howard is out for awhile do they call up a Condor forward? Hutson??
If Hyman is over his stiff neck I don’t think they need to call up anyone.
Oh yea forgot about Hyman. Wonder if he plays on the roadtrip??
Louie said he’s walking around in the dressing room which positive.
They should.
They need a shooter for PP2, and he’s reliable elsewhere on the ice.
They have 14 forwards including Hyman & 7 D .
Hyman & Levi are both on the trip.
I’ve noticed Micheals has some grease or edge to his game. Some good cross checks there. I saw a couple of times in an earlier game he was getting under players skin with after the whistle shenanigans.
Yea he seems to have some “irritation “ in his game.
Love how eat ate up Deangelo at the blueline there and muscled the puck deep with some chances generated.
Additionally, how many times have they completed a line change while in the o-zone this season so far?
It’s weird watching this game. The Islanders are getting “The Oilers Treatment” from the refs. Did someone get the referee instructions backwards?
Wow Bombers get a late turnover and then score TD to upset Argos in east semi!
They hung around in the game, the defense more or less willed them to victory and contributed a defensive touchdown.
Kinda reminds me of how the Elks have played this year. Defense kept them in it until some timely offense/picks showed up.
Wow that behind the net replay of Kap going lumberjack on that defender – and then HE gets the misconduct? I’m not sure what to do with my hands!
@Devilslettuce
Did anyone notice that Sportsnet used your post yesterday word for word? The one with the 4 stats on dump ins/battles etc. Made an infographic out of it. Around mid second period.
I was having a coffee and chat with a retired legend here in parksville about it on Thrusday while the monsoon tried washing us away.
Im gonna have to have another chat with him and see who hes been talking to 🤣
DL works at Sportsnet?
No, but I know people that associate with sportsnet.
I saw that graphic posted, word for word, a few days ago online in a screenshot from SN.
This is way less fun.
He brought it up to me, Im not sure where he was getting the information from but hes been on sportsnet over the years.
Today I learned DL = Mark Spector
I actually like hockey though lol theres all sorts of retired hockey money around these parts.
Those are Mike Kelly’s stats from SportLogiq.
https://x.com/MikeKellyNHL/status/2116197872446456280?a=duQOW9_SIOQYzqAFGqI&s=20
Interesting, Jarry 5 periods with no goals against, the bum.
Curious, how many cups would the old trap devils won with the oilers fist line plugged in there. Low event with overwhelming offensive 1st line?
maybe we should look to saw off for lines 2-4?
3 goals, and 4 assists in five games for the ageless one.
Could he be levelling-up at the age of *stares in disbelief* 33?
If so, I need some of what he’s having.
I imagine Babcock is “Ah Nuge, hockey is ah like I tell my kids, hockey is like hunting deer. It requires patience and attention to detail. Now you know you’ve been doing that your whole career, we need everyone else to dig in and do that “
Hopkins should be one of the players who benefits from Babcock substantially.
Being trusted and not having to run around as much will really suit him assuming he stays healthy.
Glad they woke up. That was trending toward one of those 2-1 stinker losses where they could have scored 10 and just plain didn’t bother.
If this continues, it will be interesting to see what Babcock focuses on after the game.
I was thinking 1-0 until it turned into 3-0.
Oilers= Roadwarriors!
lol… I think Clutterbuck is wearing his Isles jersey in the broadcast booth.
These Islander announcers are real homers.
Meh, I think they’re doing a pretty solid job. Some of the penalties have been borderline.
It’s part of the job.
The fact our current crew loves talking about every other team glowingly is an outlier. And not a good one.
Agree. It drives me nuts how often those two rave about how great the team we are playing are. I know it must hard to find new things to say about your own team but please try a little harder. Would suggest a new broadcast team would be welcome.
Nice PP goal
The witch is alive and well.
Kapanen having himself an afternoon.
Great game for Kap
Which Nuge? Yes, Nuge is a Witch.
No he’s a Sorcerer.
Scorecerer
Ok thanks 👍.
NUGE. Love it.
Just took a period to tune up the carburetor.
Tight tight tight defense.
Splendid
And in the second period too. That’s just saying how quality a period they’ve played this afternoon.
Oilers in afternoon games out east never play well to start, sometimes all game. I remember an April1 game in Washington where they had like four injuries on a Saturday and they were SO BAD on the Sunday. Had a reason that time, mind.
AFR just right.
Right at the tail-end of the PK: what a great play by Ekholm to knock the puck to the corner so that Kapanen could clear it.
Very good kill!!
That’s a penalty Freddy can’t take in the O zone. Not smart.
he shouldn’t play next game i think Jones would be better at this point
Ref screwed him on one of his three other shifts.