
One thing I believe that runs counter to most: NHL teams are often the problem when it comes to prospect development. These teams either don’t know what to do with the player (Linus Omark a famous example) or have others in the queue who are better or can do more things. The funny thing is, the stalling out often comes right at the point these men are plug-and-play. Why? I wrote the following about Omark in the summer of 2011:
By eye and by math he appears to be a real hockey player. A guy like Robert Nilsson looked all world with the puck one minute and then disappeared for the rest of the game. Omark flies sorties every shift. They don’t work out all of the time, but there’s a tremendous amount of try. He’s hard on the puck and works like a bugger. He can stickhandle in a phone booth and can beat people wide and inside. On a team with crazy skill, Omark is his own unique individual. He’s his own man, very confident and skilled.
The words on Omark are specific to that player, but the disconnect at the point where prospects reach the NHL is universal.
I think Noah Philp is such a player. He is a useful player with great utility, he has size, can PK, scores enough to project as a bottom-six NHL regular, and owns a cap hit of $775,000. He is also waiver eligible this fall. Philp is a RH center, that has high value. He does have some learning to do, as the faceoff performance in the NHL (39 percent) isn’t inspiring. Philp is a durable player, he can win battles and play a rugged game.
Last fall, Philp was solid in preseason (1-1-2 at five-on-five in six games, 57 percent faceoffs) and should be in the mix for the Derek Ryan role this fall. Not every player on a roster owns a complete skill set. I think Philp brings enough to the game to be considered for the NHL roster in Edmonton this fall.
On the Lowdown today, Jason Gregor will be the feature guest and we’ll talk Elks, Riverhawks, Stingers, Oilers of course (Rumors will have a juicy one at 12:20) and more. 12-2pm, Sports 1440. Hope you can tune in.
How could Oilers upgrade via waivers or preseason trades? 5 potential targets
https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/6545298/2025/08/11/oilers-roster-waiver-wire-trade-targets/
I think (hope) Philp can be the second coming of Kyle Brodziak. He absolutely should be given a full run to see what he can do on the 4th line.
Agreed.
Its impossible for me to waive Noah Philp and keep Janmark on the roster for close to double the cap hit. Of course, Janmark is more established and his defensive accumen more proven but I think Philp can do the job (and more being a real center and likely to score more) at more value for cap hit.
I could even throw Kapanen on that list of players that could/should be waived over Philp but their jobs are very different. Lets not forget, Kapanen fully earned many healthy scratches during the regular season and got over-capped to $1.3MM based on about 4 really good playoff games. I really like his game when he’s on but that’s rare during an 82 game season.
In any event, I hope management and the coaching staff don’t “default to Lazar” and give Philp a real opportunity – a run of 20 games at 4C (or even 4RW depending on how things break) with 10-12 minutes of 5 on 5 and some depth PK work – we’ll know what we have!
Agreed on both.
I like Kap but unless he shows another gear he’s still a tweener a la Liam Reddox (imo), with last year’s playoffs likely representing his absolute ceiling.